Evaluating Portfolio Managers Using Capture Ratios and Drawdown Metrics

Capture Ratios

Capture ratios are used to evaluate how a manager performs relative to a benchmark during periods of market gains and losses, providing insights into their suitability for different risk tolerances and investment horizons.

1. Upside Capture Ratio (UC)

• Definition: Measures the percentage of benchmark gains captured by the manager during periods when the benchmark has positive returns.
• Interpretation:
  • UC > 100%: Indicates the manager outperformed the benchmark during up markets.
  • UC < 100%: Indicates underperformance during up markets.

2. Downside Capture Ratio (DC)

• Definition: Measures the percentage of benchmark losses captured by the manager during periods when the benchmark has negative returns.
• Interpretation:
  • DC < 100%: Indicates the manager outperformed the benchmark by losing less in down markets.
  • DC > 100%: Indicates underperformance during down markets.

3. Capture Ratio (CR)

• Formula:

• Interpretation:
  • CR > 1: Positive asymmetry (convex performance). Indicates greater upside capture than downside capture.
  • CR < 1: Negative asymmetry (concave performance). Indicates greater downside capture than upside capture.

Key Insights:

• Convexity vs. Manager Skill:
  • Natural Convexity: Strategies like hedging with out-of-the-money puts can lead to positive asymmetry naturally.
  • Skill-Based Convexity: Active management that minimizes losses and maximizes gains reflects skill but may not consistently result in convexity.
• Strategy Confirmation:
  • Momentum-driven strategies often exhibit higher UC during increasing betas.
  • Value-driven strategies may have lower UC in the same conditions.
  • Low-beta strategies generally have lower UC and DC.

Drawdown Metrics

Drawdown metrics evaluate the extent and duration of losses in a portfolio, helping assess a manager’s risk management practices.

1. Drawdown

• Definition: Total peak-to-trough loss for a specified time period.
• Use: Measures the severity of losses and the risk a strategy exposes investors to.

2. Maximum Drawdown

• Definition: The largest peak-to-trough loss over the evaluation period.
• Use: Helps identify extreme loss scenarios and assess the risk tolerance compatibility of a strategy.

3. Drawdown Duration

• Definition: Total time from the beginning of a drawdown to when the drawdown is fully recovered (back to zero).
• Use: Longer drawdown durations indicate extended recovery periods, unsuitable for investors with shorter time horizons.

Applications in Manager Evaluation

1. Risk Tolerance and Time Horizon:
   • High Risk Tolerance: May accept larger drawdowns for potentially higher returns.
   • Low Risk Tolerance: Prefer managers with smaller, shorter drawdowns to minimize losses.
2. Strategy Comparison:
   • Example: A low-beta strategy with lower drawdowns may outperform a long-only strategy on a risk-adjusted basis, even with lower absolute returns.
3. Operational Insights:
   • Persistent or severe drawdowns may signal:
     • Poor investment strategies.
     • Weak internal controls.
     • Operational inefficiencies.

Practical Considerations

• Investor Suitability:
  • Short-horizon investors should favor managers with smaller and less extended drawdowns.
• Behavioral Evaluation:
  • Assess whether managers’ responses to drawdowns align with the IPS or are driven by self-preservation instincts.
• Risk Management:
  • Evaluate whether managers’ actions during drawdowns effectively manage risk without overreacting or violating the IPS.

By analyzing capture ratios and drawdown metrics, investors can evaluate the alignment of a manager’s performance with their investment goals and risk tolerance, ensuring informed manager selection and monitoring.

Advertisement