Trading Strategy Selection: Aligning Objectives with Execution

Selecting the right trading strategy is crucial for aligning execution with portfolio objectives, balancing costs, and managing risks. This guide outlines common trade types, their objectives, urgency levels, reference price benchmarks, and execution methods.

1. Short-Term Alpha Trades

Objective:

Capitalize on short-term mispricing in liquid equity markets, often driven by overreactions to news flow.

Urgency:

High, as the opportunity to generate alpha diminishes rapidly due to market adjustments.

Advertisement

Reference Prices:

• Price Target Benchmark: Reflects the manager’s view of fair value.
• Arrival Price Benchmark: Tracks the price when the order is placed in the market.

Execution Method:

• Computer Algorithms: Algorithms optimize execution speed and minimize information leakage, making them ideal for high-urgency trades.

2. Long-Term Alpha Trades

Objective:

Adjust positions over time based on fundamental changes (e.g., sell illiquid bonds with deteriorating credit conditions).

Urgency:

Low, as these trades are less time-sensitive.

Reference Prices:

Difficult to implement due to the long-term nature of these trades, which may span weeks or months.

Execution Method:

• Gradual Execution: Sell securities in small increments over time to minimize market impact and avoid alerting dealers or the market to the trade.

3. Risk Rebalance

Objective:

Rebalance or hedge exposures (e.g., liquidate FX positions to reduce portfolio volatility).

Urgency:

Low, as trades on both sides (buying and selling) reduce execution risk compared to one-sided trades.

Reference Prices:

• TWAP (Time-Weighted Average Price): Reduces the impact of extreme prices by averaging trades over time.

Execution Method:

• Algorithmic Execution: Target TWAP over several days, aligning trading activity with time-based averages.

4. Cash Flow-Driven Trades for Client Redemption

Objective:

Liquidate holdings to meet redemption requests calculated based on the closing price of securities.

Urgency:

High, as trades must be completed by the end of the trading day to align with closing price calculations.

Reference Prices:

• Closing Price: Ensures alignment with redemption values.

Execution Method:

• Participate in the closing auction for a portion of the trade to minimize tracking error.
• Execute the remainder at VWAP during the day to balance liquidity needs.

5. Cash Flow-Driven Trades for New Mandates

Objective:

Invest new client funds, ensuring immediate exposure to a benchmark while adhering to tracking error constraints (e.g., small-cap index).

Urgency:

Immediate exposure is required, but underlying securities may not be liquid enough for same-day execution.

Reference Prices:

• Closing Price: Used to measure performance from the mandate’s inception.

Execution Method:

1. Index Futures: Enter long positions in liquid futures contracts to eliminate cash drag and achieve immediate exposure.
2. Underlying Securities: Build positions gradually in the underlying index components to minimize market impact, reducing the futures position concurrently.

Considerations:

• Ensure the fund mandate permits derivatives.
• If futures lack a closing auction, execute the trade as close to the market close as possible.

Key Takeaways

Conclusion

Effective trading strategies align with the specific objectives and constraints of the trade. By carefully selecting reference price benchmarks and execution methods, managers can balance market impact, execution risk, and client requirements, ensuring optimal outcomes across various scenarios.